FREE Shipping on orders over $59
Best Pegging Toys for Beginners | First Timers Buyers Guide

Best Pegging Toys for Beginners | First Timers Buyers Guide

Shopping for the best pegging toys online for the first time can be confusing. Technically, there is no such thing as a sex shop category solely called “pegging toys” rather, they are a collection of thin dildos, suction cup vibrators, small butt plugs, slender anal probes, dildo, tiny prostate toys and curved anal sex toys.

Now combine this basket full of sex toys and figure out which ones are compatible with a strap on harness, and now you have a pegging sex toys kit. Confusing? If you're not well versed in the sexual satisfaction industry like we are, then yes, buying the best beginner pegging toys can be very confusing for couples who are searching for information for the first time.

Beginners take note, I've created this best pegging toys online buyers guide to help you select a great combination of items for the first time that will fulfill this new kinky woman on man anal sex fantasy. If you want a definition before you begin, make sure to check out what is pegging for the full details and some tips on potions and suggestions for couples to make the experience more enjoyable.

Before we begin, it should be noted there are 2 types of pegging toys:

  1. Strap On for Pegging
  2. Pegging Dildo

It's simple math, 1+2 = 3. Combine a strap on with a dildo and you now have a pegging sex toy! Why?Pegging definition” is the act of anal penetration of a man by a woman wearing a strap on dildo harness. It's also known as role reversal.

The best pegging definition is now becoming a little more relaxed as now a woman does not need to wear a strap on, she can simply insert the device into her partner's butt by hand and stimulate the sensitive nerve endings. The definition is evolving a bit as time goes on. Most partners who shop stick to the original pegging definition and purchase both components: The pegging dildo or vibrator and a separate dildo harness for the attachment. Advanced users also select a bullet vibrator for her and a unisex strap-on harness for the best pegging experience possible.

This best pegging toys guide is also useful for men & women who are preparing for anal sex because these plugs & dildos are ideally sized for anal training. You don't necessarily need your lover to be present, you can try these alone during masturbation to get used to the feel of anal penetration. Don't forget we have a free shipping offer, so the more dildos and toys you buy, the more you save.

10 Best Pegging Toys for Beginners (in order)

Mini Curved

1. Mini Curved Pegging Toy

This is the quintessential pegging dildo for beginners. Mini Curved does everything right, and nothing wrong. The tiny realistic dildo has a steep curve perfect for pinpoint prostate stimulation and the extra wide base will fit in any size harness ring.

The shaft can bend slightly, but remains stiff enough for anal insertion. The mini size won't scare him and make him pucker up either, this is the smallest of all anal sex appropriate dildos. This is my top rated realistic dildo for pegging first timers.

  • Natural curve made for prostate stimulation
  • Wide base fits into any strap on ring
  • The smallest realistic pegging toy
  • 5 inches long, 3 1/2 inches insertable
 
Temptasia

2. Temptasia

The best pegging toy for first timers because it's less than 1 inch wide, but long enough so he can actually feel it in his butt. Temptasia is a super stylish flexible probe with a heart shaped base that looks feminine yet naughty when fixed to the harness that she wears.

This is a must-have accessory, the pure silicone feels like silk and is non-porous so it's easy to sanitize after use with antibacterial soap or sex toy cleaner. The shaft can bend at any point so as it slides in his butthole it never pokes in a place that won't feel good. It follows the curves and passageways of his rectum and feels great!

  • Seamless smooth probe for easy penetration
  • Heart shaped base has a feminine touch of class
  • The smallest silicone pegging toy
  • 4 1/2 inches long, 3/4 inch across
 
Triple Play Glass

3. Triple Play Glass

Glass anal sex toys are wildly popular these days, and I truly believe they make the best pegging toy too. Triple Play Glass is a harness compatible glass probe with a smooth shaft and graduated ripples that feel oh-so invigorating during insertion.

The slippery surface is a delight when the partner thrusts and even though it's made of solid glass, this lightweight Pyrex style glass butt plug is super easy to maneuver and non-porous so it's the most hygienic and sanitary sex toy. My top rated pick!

  • Glass is hygienic & hypoallergenic
  • 3 ¾ inches long
  • Less than 1 inch diameter
  • Solid glass
 
Booty Teaser

4. Booty Teaser

Although this is a small butt plug, the Booty Teaser makes the best pegging toy for beginners. The thin silicone shaft has a rounded end and thin neck to add a massaging feel to his sphincter while his partner thrusts.

The comfortable thinner neck can bend easily and the silky feeling luxurious silicone surface is a nice quality upgrade compared to the typical rubber anal plug. The anchor shaped base grabs onto the strap on ring and stays in place.

  • Anchor shaped base for external teasing
  • Pure silicone
  • 4 inches long
  • Less than 1 inch diameter
 
Slim Suction Penis

5. Slim Suction Penis

The longest pegging sex toy for sale, the ribbed realistic Slim Suction Penis is also the most popular pegging dildo for first timers, but many partners may not realize the flared base fits through a small strap on harness ring.

The slender elongated shaft is floppy, so you'll need 2 hands to insert it into his butt, but once inside he can dictate how deep you should go. The diameter may be a tad wide for a first timer, but if he likes the feel of prostate plugs or anal probes, he'll truly enjoy this ribbed wonder.

  • The longest pegging toy
  • 2 sizes available
  • Flexible rubber shaft
  • Rounded head for easy insertion
 
4 Inch Whopper

6. 4 Inch Whopper

Pegging vibrators are few and far between, but we've hand picked the little 4 Inch Whopper, which was originally made for women to be used by partners as a vibrating pegging toy instead. The realistic penis shaped shaft has a stuff enough build to insert far into his ass, yet the shaft is bendable enough to move with your bodies as you change positions.

The intense, super powerful vibration has enough strength to fire his ejaculation across the room, it greatly improves his orgasm, and is a must have small vibrator for couples who like intense couples adult toys.

  • Most powerful vibrating pegging toy
  • Steady stovepipe shaft
  • 4 ¾ inches insertable
  • Available in beige or brown
 
His and Hers Plug

7. Silicone Willy

The flat circular base stays put in your strap on ring, and the thin head that gradually increases in girth along the shaft offers him a nice, cushy stretch. He can tell you how to deep to go depending on how much he's enjoying the increasing diameter. The small penis head is 1 inch wide and the shaft increases to 1 1/4 inches near the base of the shaft (before the suction cup begins).

Silicone Willy is made of smooth silky skin like silicone that inserts really comfortably and the curved shaft is flexible so you can move around without poking his rectum. This is the highest quality, softest pegging toy available for sale from our shop.

  • Softest pegging toy
  • Graduated shaft adds pleasure
  • Flared base fits any strap on ring
  • Hypoallergenic & unscented pure silicone
 
BFF Petite

8. BFF Petite Pegging Toy

We love this shape, it's the quintessential smooth unisex and non-binary anal toy that goes super deep with all the flex to keep it cozy. BFF Petite may be too thick for someone who's never inserted an anal probe before, but if your man has used butt plugs during masturbation or sex in the past, this one shouldn't be too far of an upgrade for him.

The shape is excellent for guys who think pegging is gay, the non-phallic shape won't make him feel strange during sex and the slight upwards curve is ergonomic when you're enjoying strap on anal sex. The cheap price can't be beat either!

  • Non-phallic pegging toy
  • Cheaply priced
  • Natural curve reaches the prostate
  • Popular size upgrade for men
 
Naughty Plug

9. Naughty Plug

There are 2 sizes of Naughty Plug, so many lovers purchase both and use the small one first then upgrade to the large plug once he's used to the sensation. Using a dildo like this is is also known as “anal training”. It has the standard plug shape, but if you know the purpose of a butt plug you'll understand it's application for this type of sex play.

The anchor base is harness compatible and the thick forward curved tip massages the prostate instantly upon insertion. It's the easiest pegging toy to locate the prostate and even though some have thinner tips, the flared end here has larger space to cover inside the body, therefore ensuring the prostate will be touched!

  • Made for the male prostate
  • Comes in 2 sizes for training
  • Wide tip massages deep
  • Premium silicone
 
Anal Training Kit

10. Anal Training Kit

This is a collection that includes all 3 of the dildo butt plugs as shown. All 3 of these are harness compatible, husbands and wives love to use the Anal Training Kit as pegging toys because they shaft are longer, longer toys are easier to use during pegging strap on anal sex.

The jelly soft rubber is super bendable so you can give him a good ramming from behind and it won't hurt his anus. This is a secret accessory that lovers swear by, the size range between small to large is quite vast so this collection is all a couple needs. We think it should take a top spot in your list too.

  • Kit includes 3 pegging toys
  • Each toy has a different size & shape
  • Soft & malleable rubber for comfort
  • Available in 3 colors
 
Swizzle

11. Swizzle Pegging Toy

The Swizzle is the thinnest anal toy ever made, so if a guy is interested in trying pegging but refuses to use anything large, the ultra thin Swizzle dildo is the best choice, It's thinner than a finger and the round bead at the end is there for a reason: So your partner can press it in to your anus with a “pop” similar to anal beads.

The extra long shaft can go super deep and the spiraled surface adds a funky texture while she thrusts from behind. The base is also a handle, so she can use it to ram or poke or explore, it's the perfect kinky adult toy for kinky couples. Creativity is your key to using this strange and unique device for pure sexual pleasure, and we like to suggest it as the most original and unique thin pegging toy for beginners.

  • Thinner than a finger
  • Bulb at the tip aids in insertion
  • The longest & thinnest pegging toy
  • Firm silicone retains its shape
 

Best Harness For Your Pegging Toy

The Innovation

The Innovation is the best strap on for beginners because it has a high quality luxurious streamlined design at a cheap price to support silicone dildos. Sure we've seen cheaper harnesses for sale, but this one is actually nice and super comfortable for her to wear.

It has a cloth lining and hemmed in ring that has better feminine styling. It can be dressed up a naughty or nice, this is our most versatile harness option and the newest pegging strap on. The thong style back looks ultra sexy and the whole thing can be hand washed.

  • Soft fabric harness
  • Sexy G-string style back
  • Stretchy rubber O-ring sewn into the fabric
  • Fits up to a 50 inch waist
 
SX Harness

SX harness is our favorite budget option that is durable and well made. The silky soft straps won't chafe, the imitation leather harness backing has a dark and demure appearance similar to what a dominatrix would wear kin the bedroom. Perfect for acting up your erotic sex fantasy! There is even room up front for her to use a bullet vibe.

Includes 2 rubber O rings allowing more variance in attachment sizes compared to the first option, however most couples who peg choose thin and small attachments so having a large O ring is not an important feature, but versatility is always nice; you never know what the future holds!

  • Most inexpensive option
  • Made to fit small pegging toys
  • Imitation leather harness
  • Fits up to a 48 inch waist
 
Pegged Harness Kit

Pegged Harness Kit is the best pegging strap on dildo set because it saves you the step of shopping for an attachment separately by including a pure silicone dildo for him. Pure silicone is a real selling feature because it's easy to sterilize and hypoallergenic.

The top third curves slight upwards to encourage the shaft to make contact with his prostate gland upon penetration. The mere 7/8 inch width is not intimidating to him, but be sure to add thick butt lube to make that first insertion much smoother. The dildo can be removed form the harness ring so you can mix and match with the other best pegging toys listed above.

  • Pouch sewn in the back of the harness so the wearer can insert her vibrator
  • Stylish shiny PVC harness looks great
  • Includes a small pure silicone dildo
  • Dildo has a curve for male prostate stimulation
 

Pegging Toy Videos

The following pegging toys videos include small dildos that are well suited for anal insertion. If you wonder what the actual size looks like in relation to the body, these demonstration will give you an accurate idea of what they look like upon entry.

The best pegging toys also include the possibility of a dildo that is originally intended for women, but in our experience, they are perfectly suited for guys who want to try backdoor penetration for the first time. Make sure to keep your options open when shopping online for pegging accessories!

All of these dildo and butt plugs can be worn on a strap on harness for first time pegging, but as seen in the video demonstrations, they can be used alone during male masturbation. In fact, it's one of the best ways for guys to get used to the feeling of anal.

Guys go at the pace they choose and as deep or as shallow as they decide. Invite her into the room after you've given yourself a nice introductory lesson on the first timer pegging toys you like best. Before you shop online, make sure to check out the following suggestions that beginners like most:

 

Beginner & Intermediate Butt Plug

I think the ordinary, classic shaped butt plug makes the perfect pegging toy for beginners. The flat base always stays inside the harness O-ring and will never slip out. They are stiff enough to insert without too much fumbling, which makes the entire experience easy and fast. Start with the Small size and then introduce him to the Medium size once his rectum has been stretched enough. (Each size option is sold separately.)

 

Mood Blue

A pegging toy you'll only see here! Why? Normally sold as an anal sex toy only, I've modified it's designated category and moved Mood Blue into my list of best pegging toys for men. It just happens to have the right curve for prostate stimulation and the anchor shaped curved base is permanently held snug in the strap on ring (until you remove thew harness and slide it out from the ring, of course!)

 

Jellie Anal Trainer Kit

The perfect pack of pegging dildos that combine both anal training and pegging sex into one! Jellie Anal Trainers are super soft with graduated bumps, they squish into the anus oh-so delightfully. The size difference between the small and large is just enough to take that one step further into male anal stretching. The high quality jelly won't leave a tacky mess when mixed with thick anal lube either.

 

Anal Starter

Shaped like a small penis with more flexibility than an average anal dildo, Anal Starter is a fine dildo for him, but one thing must be taken into consideration before attaching it to your stapon: The base is flared, but only slightly. It will fall out of an ordinary ring, so take a trip to a hardware store and buy a smaller rubber O ring to snap onto your harness. Then the dildo will fit without an issue. Since it's so soft, you might need a little maneuvering for initial entry, as demonstrated in the video.

 

Conclude with Pegging Sex Toys Lube

As a final note before we conclude, Pegging Lube is an important add-on that improves pleasure and makes the dildo penetration experience more enjoyable. Which one to buy? Thick water based anal sex lube is the best pegging lube.

A viscous gel is less runny that a vaginal lube, and the water based style cleans easily. Make sure to select water based lube only because if you have a silicone pegging toy, silicone lube will melt the surface over time. Add one of the lubricant applicators to reduce mess and make sure the lube doesn't spill out of his anus.

When it comes to anal penetration from any combination of anal toys, lubricant is absolutely the most important aspect to consider. The anus does not lubricate itself like the vagina does and when the partner tries to squeeze a dildo into the tight anus sphincter, it can cause serious discomfort, even tearing the tissue.

The solution to preventing this is to properly use lube. It's such a hot topic that I've even created a completely dedicated blog entry talking about the importance of personal lube and sharing ways to apply it to make anal not hurt. The last thing you want to do is get off on a painful start, especially when partners are involved because we want this new experience to be a good one!



Click to buy pegging dildos & strap ons online.



Mayla Green

Mayla Green has been involved in the sex toy industry since 2004. Working behind the motto “Sex TOYS should be FUN”, Mayla provides unique tips & advice amassed from over a decade of hands on experience with adult products. She also coaches clients how to fully enjoy sexual pleasure and can be seen in major publications & magazines online.

Happily married since 2009, she knows firsthand how the sex life eventually becomes repetitive (which truthfully means boring), so if you're looking to spice things up in the bedroom, Mayla's your gal! Her literary pride & joy is covering topics for established couples needing inspiration to keep lovemaking exciting and fun.

Not in a relationship? Her other focus is teaching women how to properly handle the “little person in the canoe” to experience the best orgasms ever, no partner required! Her creative and innovative tips, techniques and advice is on par with a certified sex therapist or Sexologist, but with an extra advantage from her knowledge of the adult toy business.

View all articles published by Mayla Green exclusively for The Adult Toy Shop sex blog. Mayla Green's Linkedin profile highlights her professional background, experience and training.

Related Posts
  1. How Do Inflatable Butt Plugs Work? | What They Feel Like How Do Inflatable Butt Plugs Work? | What They Feel Like Watch videos of inflatable butt plugs inflate & deflate. What is an inflatable butt plug and why would a person want to try one? I can tell you exactly why, and even explain what they feel like inside the butt. They are fragile anal toys, so proper
  2. How to Use Clit Suckers & Clit Pumps How to Use Clit Suckers & Clit Pumps How do I use a clit sucker, and what does it feel like? A peculiar little sex toy for powerful female arousal. Step by step instructions on using a clit pump and a comparison of the 4 different styles that a lady can choose from. Learn details on ex
  3. Best Quiet Vibrators - Sound Testing 25 Vibrators Best Quiet Vibrators - Sound Testing 25 Vibrators What makes a vibrator quiet? And other common FAQ's. We receive plenty of questions about quiet vibrators. This guide answers everything you've ever wanted to know and even includes tips to make a noisy vibrator silent. I bring out the sound meter a
  4. Most Powerful Vibrators | Reviewed & Compared Most Powerful Vibrators | Reviewed & Compared Have you ever reached an orgasm in seconds with a vibrator before? Powerful vibrators are a hot commodity in the bedroom, but it's difficult to shop for one just by looking at photos online. In this buyers guide, I'll provide explanations as to why
Related Products
    1. T Anal Vibe
      T Anal Vibe
      $12.14 $14.99 You Save $2.85
    2. The Anal Stuffer
      The Anal Stuffer
      $15.38 $18.99 You Save $3.61
    3. Anal Prostate Stimulator
      Anal Prostate Stimulator
      $11.33 $13.99 You Save $2.66
    4. Inflatable Anal Balloon
      Inflatable Anal Balloon
      $21.67 $26.99 You Save $5.32
    5. Beginner's Anal Tickler
      Beginner's Anal Tickler
      $24.29 $29.99 You Save $5.70
    6. Mini Beginners Anal Toy
      Mini Beginners Anal Toy
      $20.24 $24.99 You Save $4.75
    7. Thick Anal Lube
      Thick Anal Lube
      SOLD OUT
    8. ID Jelly Lube - 2 Sizes
      ID Jelly Lube - 2 Sizes
      $14.57 $17.99 You Save $3.42
    9. Perfect Plug Anal Prostate Toy
      Perfect Plug Anal Prostate Toy
      $18.62 $22.99 You Save $4.37
    10. Fun Flex Long Anal Wand Toy
      Fun Flex Long Anal Wand Toy
      $13.76 $16.99 You Save $3.23
    11. Booty Shaker Silicone Anal Toy
      Booty Shaker Silicone Anal Toy
      $16.19 $19.99 You Save $3.80
    12. Anal Delight
      Anal Delight
      $13.12 $15.99 You Save $2.87
    13. Vibro Butt Buddy Anal Toy
      Vibro Butt Buddy Anal Toy
      $22.67 $27.99 You Save $5.32
    14. Ass-gasm Male Sex Toy
      Ass-gasm Male Sex Toy
      $21.05 $25.99 You Save $4.94
    15. Slim Suction Penis Dildo
      Slim Suction Penis
      $14.92 $18.99 You Save $4.07
    16. Butt Plug - Beginner
      Butt Plug - Beginner
      $12.14 $14.99 You Save $2.85
    17. Mini Whopper Tiny Realistic Dildo
      Mini Whopper
      $21.36 $26.99 You Save $5.63
    18. Mini Whopper Vibrator
      Mini Whopper Vibrator
      $37.77 $46.99 You Save $9.22
    19. Small curved g-spot dildo
      Major Dick - Small Dildo
      $18.71 $23.99 You Save $5.28
    20. Probe for Anal Pegging
      Bff Petite Dildo Sex Toy
      $11.33 $13.99 You Save $2.66
    21. Cloud 9 Mini Realistic Dildo
      Cloud 9 Mini Dildo Toy
      SOLD OUT
    22. Xl Lube Applicator
      Xl Lube Applicator
      $10.08 $12.99 You Save $2.91
    23. Mini Curved Pegging Toy
      Mini Curved Male Dildo
      $19.34 $23.99 You Save $4.65
    24. Cloud 9 Fresh Anal Douche Kit
      Cloud 9 Fresh Anal Douche Kit
      $26.72 $32.99 You Save $6.27