FREE Shipping on orders over $59
25 Best Butt Plugs | Best for Beginners, Vibrating, Men & Women

25 Best Butt Plugs | Best for Beginners, Vibrating, Men & Women

Last Updated on June 30, 2021

When it comes to anal play, where's your head at? Are you a curious beginner, seasoned pro, or somewhere in between? Have you introduced toys into your anal play routine? If you haven't, you should. One great place to start is by buying the best butt plug.

Before I list the best butt plugs to try, divided within different categories such as vibrating, for beginners, for men, for women, glass and inflatable, I will pay homage to the beginner and cover everything you need to know about butt plugs. You'll learn why they're so amazing, what kind of butt plugs you can get, and the best care in use of your butt plug.

Butt Why? So Many Orgasms, so Little Time.

Like most other toys, the best butt plug use boils down to one thing, the orgasm. Here are just a few of the many ways high quality butt plugs can bring you to climax:

  • They provide prostate stimulation for men.
  • When a butt plug is inserted, a woman's vaginal opening is narrowed. This can lead to more intense intercourse for her and her partner.
  • Using a butt plug while masturbating can create mind-blowing orgasms.
  • Butt plugs are a great anal training tool. After practicing with anal toys, many people can enjoy very intense orgasmic anal sex sessions.

You Just Gotta Know How to Use ‘em Right

With many sex toys, you can just experiment until you figure out what you like. What does a butt plug do? With your butt plug, there are definitely some best practices. Found some basic guidelines to ensure that you are engaging in safe play, and that your butt plug is well taken care of.

Let's keep it real. A clean workspace is very important here. You don't want to spend your experience feeling self-conscious and worrying. You also don't want to deal with a mess. In most cases, going to the bathroom shortly before you start anal play is plenty. You can also use an anal douche to ensure things are spotless.

Best Butt Plugs
Beginner to expert and everything in between!

Start Small

Don't be intimidated by the thought of inserting and wearing a large plug. These toys are sold in all sizes, and the best way to begin is with something small.

These small anal plugs are often referred to as trainers. In most cases these are easier to insert and keep in place. Practice with a small plug that is comfortable for you. Then, move up through other sizes as you continue to challenge yourself.

For a small butt plug try one of these:

  • The Booty Rocker: This tiny butt plug is ideal for fun anal play for beginners. This silicone toy is 4 inches (10.16 centimeters) long, and 1 inch (25.4 mm) in diameter at its largest point.
  • Candy Rimmer Small: Check out this slim, sil-a-gel butt plug. It’s one of the tiniest on the market, and allows users to experience anal play without discomfort or stress.
  • Spectra Gel Anal Plug: Try this super soft plug with a sensuous curve. It’s sure to hit all the right spots.

Best Butt Plugs For One And All: To Each Their Own

If you think you don't like butt plugs, you could be right. On the other hand, you simply may not have read the right anal toy information that interests you. The best butt plugs come in a variety of shapes and sizes. They're also made out of a variety of materials. Here are some of the most common. Think about what appeals to you, and then go shopping.

  • Basic Beginner Plug: This small, flexible butt plug is great fun for guys or gals.
  • Butt Plug Advanced: Like the name suggests, this one is for experienced users. If you have engaged in lots of anal play, and enjoy size play, take this one as a challenge. Not quite ready for the challenge? Try the Beginner or Intermediate versions. These come from the same maker, but are simply scaled down.
  • Hung Plug: So many butt plugs are wide. It’s difficult to find one that is more about length than girth. This one is the best butt plug for length.
  • Booty Teaser: This is a small, soft bendable toy. It’s a best rated butt plug that many customers have praised.

When it comes to anal toys, especially for beginners, softer is definitely better. Remember that these toys are intended to be worn for a period of time. The last thing you want is something that feels like it’s stabbing you from the inside. Consider trying a silicone or soft rubber plug at first.

Later, you might try glass or stainless steel plugs. These create some amazing sensations, but you should be certain you choose quality butt plugs, and that you get the right size.

List of 25 Best Butt Plugs

What exactly makes the best butt plug? It depends who you ask. Everyone has a different opinion and these are not targeted towards a specific user class, they are based on sales volume and customer reviews. It's a perfect list to get some inspiration on new styles and features that you may not have considered before.

5 Best Vibrating Butt Plugs:

vibra plug

1. Vibra Plug

Vibra Plug is the best vibrating butt plug with the cheapest price – even though it's cheap, we still think is just fabulous. Nice and solid medium size plug with excellent super powerful tingling vibration. Buy this one and enjoy great bang for the buck!

  • Insertable Length: 3 1/2 inches
  • Diameter: 1/2 inch tip, 1 1/4 inches at the thickest point
  • Motor: 3 speeds
  • Material: Firm rubber plug, plastic bullet

pulsating plug

2. Pulsating Plug

Pulsating Plug features different vibrating patterns in a stout penis shaped form with heavy set veins for an insane experience in the derriere. The short stature yet thicker girth fits petite men and women better than most large size butt plugs.

  • Length: 4 1/4 inches
  • Diameter: 1 1/2 inch
  • Motor: 4 pulsating patterns
  • Material: Firm rubber

corked plug

3. Corked Vibro Plug

Corked Vibro Plug has a super thin tapered neck and resists falling out of the anus. Silky feeling yet solid toy tingles ferociously inside the body. One of our all-time favorites for more advanced users, a must-buy with loads of power.

  • Insertable Length: 4 1/4 inches
  • Diameter: Slightly over 1 1/4 inches at the thickest point
  • Motor: Single speed
  • Material: Silicone

booty call kit

4. Booty Call Kit

Booty Call Kit brings home all anal pleasures in one easy package. Can't decide between anal beads & plug? This is the best vibrating anal toys kit for beginners with 2 separate toys plus a removable vibrating bullet.

  • Insertable Length: Beads: 4 1/2 inches - Plug: 4 inches
  • Diameter: Beads: 1 1/8 inch across the largest bead, ¾ inches across the smallest bead – Plug: 1 inch at the thickest point
  • Motor: Multi speed
  • Material: Silicone plug & beads, Plastic vibrator

mini vibro plug

5. Mini Vibro Plug

Mini Vibro Plug is soft like jelly to give the first timer an experience they'll love. After you've inserted the squishy small tip, the solid vibrator in the middle of the belly tingles around your anus, a nice thrill for newbies.

  • Insertable Length: 4 inches
  • Diameter: 1 inch
  • Motor: Push-button 1 speed
  • Material: TPE silicone

5 Best Beginner Butt Plugs:

booty rocker

1. Booty Rocker

Booty Rocker is our number 1 best butt plug for beginners. The small size has the ideal girth thin as a finger for first timers. The bulb at the end insteps easily while the anchor shaped base tucks nicely and holds the device in place.

  • Length: 4 inches
  • Diameter: 1 inch at the thickest point
  • Material: Pure silicone
  • Color Options: Black, Purple

platinum bubble

2. Platinum Bubble

Platinum Bubble is a cool combination of anal beads and plug with the ideal forward facing curve that enhances G spot contact during sex and encourages prostate stimulation for men. High quality totally luxurious silicone lasts a lifetime too.

  • Length: 3 inches
  • Diameter: Slightly under 1 inch at the thickest point
  • Material: Premium silicone
  • Size Options: Small, Large

apollo

3. Apollo

Apollo is originally a prostate massager for men, but we like to suggest it to beginners because it's thin as a finger and has the curve to enhance sensation for women while using a vibrator or during sex. The only anal plug with a handle built in!

  • Length: 4 1/2 inches
  • Diameter: Slightly under 1 inch
  • Material: Silicone

platinum smooth

4. Platinum Smooth

Platinum Smooth is shaped like the pinky finger for consistent pressure best for beginners. It's easy and simple and our best butt plug for first timers who want to keep size to a minimum. Luxurious pure silicone always feels good back there.

  • Length: 4 inches
  • Diameter: 7/8 inch at the thickest point
  • Material: Premium silicone
  • Color Options: Black, Pink

butt plug beginner

5. Beginner Butt Plug

Beginner Butt Plug is obviously the best choice with a name like that! The original, standard and quintessential option for first timers with long length to get deep without going too wide. Soft bendable rubber is gentle and forgiving.

  • Length: 4 1/4 inches
  • Diameter: 3/4 inch at the thinnest point, 7/8 inch at the widest point
  • Material: Sil-a-Gel
  • Color Options: Black, Beige

5 Best Butt Plugs for Men:

mood blue

1. Mood Blue

Mood Blue has 2 size options to choose from assuring every guy can receive his ideal size. The best butt plug for men reaches the prostate gland effortlessly upon insertion. Narrow neck prevents it from falling out. Set it and forget it!

  • Insertable Length: 3 inches
  • Diameter: Slightly under 1 inch at the thickest point
  • Material: Premium Silicone
  • Size Options: Small, Large

ass gasm

2. Ass Gasm

Ass-gasm is a bit on the kinky size, but this penis ring butt plug combo is perfect for men to wear during masturbation. The strand connecting the cock ring and plug pushes on the scrotum for added sexual pleasure.

  • Length: 4 inches
  • Diameter: 1 1/4 inches across the widest point
  • Ring Diameter: Slightly over 1 1/2 inches
  • Material: Soft silicone

ram bumpy plug

3. Ram Bumpy Plug

Ram Bumpy Plug is our best butt plug for men looking for something more intense. Thick bulbous shaft with irregular ribbed texture feels unique compared to any other style and the retrieval loop is a stylish rendition with manly appeal.

  • Insertable Length: 4 inches
  • Diameter: 1 inch at the tip, 1 1 /4 inches near the base
  • Material: Pure silicone
  • Color Options: Black, Beige

ultimate locator

4. Ultimate Locator

Ultimate Locator has an immediate fat girth and wide bulbous flared belly that reaches the prostate and presses it relentlessly. It's wider than most toys so make sure you're well versed in anal toy usage before attempting this big beast!

  • Length: 4 1/2 inches
  • Diameter: 1/2 inch at the tip, 1 1/2 inches at the thickest point
  • Material: Pure silicone

medium cock plug

5. Medium Cock Plug

Medium Cock Plug is not only the best butt plug for gay men, but straight dudes like it because it fills the anal cavity just right. The long shaft with penis shaped tip adds deep down pressure that makes male ejaculations feel stronger than ever.

  • Length: 6 inches
  • Diameter: 1 1/2 inches across the thickest point
  • Material: Rubber
  • Color Options: Black, Beige

5 Best Butt Plugs for Women:

cosmic plug

1. Cosmic Plug

Cosmic Plug is the best butt plug for women because not only is it super pretty, but the soft surface does not pinch or punch when sliding in the back door. It's available in 2 sizes assuring every gal can find her favorite size option.

  • Length: 4 1/4 inches
  • Diameter: Slightly over 1 1/4 inches at the thickest point
  • Material: Soft PVC rubber
  • Size Options: Small, Medium

pretty pink plug

2. Pretty N Pink

Pretty N Pink is the girliest, most feminine anal toy we've ever seen. It's the best choice for ladies who don't want naughty or kinky adult toys but prefer to keep things classy. It's the softest and squishiest option for pure, utter comfort.

  • Insertable Length: 3 3/4 inches
  • Diameter: 3/4 inch tip, 1 3/8 inches at the thickest point
  • Material: TPR silicone

booty probe

3. Booty Probe

Booty Probe is the most stylish vibrating butt plug for women. Ooozing with sophistication, this modern style features intense vibration and a smooth silicone surface. It's too big for a total newbie, but experienced users will love it!

  • Insertable Length: 3 3/4 inches
  • Diameter: 1 1/2 inches across the thickest part
  • Motor: 3 speed
  • Material: Silicone

platinum spade

4. Platinum Spade

Platinum Spade has such a fabulous shape. We wish more anal toys were shaped like this. Short yet wide adds pressure directly behind the rectum amplifying sensation from masturbation or intercourse. Extra thin neck prevents it from popping out.

  • Length: 4 inches
  • Diameter: Slightly under 1 1/2 inches at the thickest point
  • Material: Premium silicone

booty beads

5. Booty Beads

Booty Beads are the anal beads you can wear! The angle fits the curvature of the rectum just right while the bulbous shaft has a unique feel to enhance pleasure. You can pull them out like beads at the onset or orgasm, or leave it in place like a plug.

  • Length: 5 inches
  • Diameter: 3/4 at the tip, 1 1/4 inches across the widest bulb
  • Material: Pure silicone
  • Color Options: Pink, Purple

5 Best Inflatable Butt Plugs:

expandable plug

1. Expandable Plug

Expandable Plug is the best inflatable butt plug because it inflates quickly and has minimal cords and wires for the least amount of distraction. It's the ideal option for first timers who want an expanding anal toy, but too big for the true beginner. What does an inflatable butt plug feel like? Check this out now if you're curious!

  •  Length: 4 1/2 inches
  • Deflated Diameter: Slightly under 1 1/2 inches
  • Inflated Diameter: 3 1/2 inches
  • Material: Rubber butt plug & tubing, Latex rubber coating over the plug

deluxe inflatable pug

2. Deluxe Inflating Plug

Deluxe Inflating Plug adds vibration to the mix creating a echoing tingle while the balloon inflates in your butt. It's the original inflatable butt plug with vibration and is still a customer favorite and one of the most reliable with positive reviews.

  • Length: 5 inches
  • Deflated Diameter: 1 1/2 inches
  • Inflated Diameter: Just under 3 inches
  • Motor: Multi speed

the ram plug

3. The Ram

The Ram is just under 6 inches long with a narrow tip and wider base so it's a good intermediate option for men and women looking to upgrade size. It inflates in a round, circular shape right in the middle and also features silent vibration.

  • Length: 5 1/2 inches
  • Deflated Diameter: 3/4 inch near the tip, 1 3/8 inches near the base
  • Inflated Diameter: 3 1/4 inches
  • Motor: Multi speed

inflatable balloon

4. Inflatable Balloon

Inflatable Balloon is not technically a plug per-se, but it's the best inflating anal toy for first timers. It is the smallest and thinnest upon insertion and it expands in a stout, round form inside the rectum. Perfect for trying something different!

  • Length: 17 inches from bulb to balloon
  • Deflated Diameter: 1/2 an inch
  • Inflated Diameter: 2 1/2 inches
  • Material: Latex rubber tip, PVC rubber tubing

medium silicone plug

5. Medium Silicone Inflatable Plug

Medium Silicone Inflatable Plug is the only latex free inflatable anal toy. If you have latex allergies but want to try an inflatable anal toy, this should be your top choice. This best selling option is the modern wave of the future for expanding plugs.

  • Length: 5 inches
  • Deflated Diameter: 1 1/4 inches
  • Inflated Diameter: 3 inches
  • Material: Silicone butt plug & tubing

5 Best All Day Anal Plugs:

deluxe prostate

1. Deluxe Anal Prostate Toy

Deluxe Anal Prostate Toy is the best butt plug to wear all day long because the base is a highly flexible silicone strand that stays tucked away and won't make a bulge in your pants. No one will know you're wearing the butt plug all day.

  • Length: 5 3/4 inches
  • Diameter: 1 1/4 inch at the tip, 1/2 inch at thinnest part
  • Material: Pure silicone

mood plug

2. Mood Plug

Mood Plug is the best all day butt plug for those who don't want anything too big. This small silicone option has an anchor shaped base with plenty of flex to tuck between your cheeks and remain in place out of view from the public.

  • Length: Slightly under 4 inches
  • Diameter: Maximum 1 inch
  • Material: Pure silicone
  • Color Options: Black, Pink

raging plug

3. Raging Hard On Plug

Raging Hard On Plug is the kinky choice of freaky folks. Heavily veined penis shaped shaft with short and stout stature adds extra pressure directly over the most sensitive spots. Not for the faint of heart, yet suits both male and female experts.

  • Length: 4 1/2 inches
  • Diameter: Maximum 1 3/4 inches
  • Material: Sil-a-Gel

spectra

4. Spectra Gel

Spectra Gel is one of the softest butt plugs we've ever seen. The high quality silicone feels jelly soft. The shaft has a forward angle to enhance G-spot and prostate pleasure for him and her. A great trainer tool too since it's a good step up for the first timer.

  • Length: 4 inches
  • Diameter: 1 inch
  • Material: Spectra Gel (soft rubber)

wiggler

5. Wiggler

Wiggler is a ribbed anal toy with thin yet sturdy retrieval strand and discreet self contained vibrator. It buzzes under your clothes in public and as long you're not in a silent place, no one will know you're wearing the butt plug all day long.

  • Insertable Length: 3 inches
  • Diameter: Ranges between 1 - 1 1/4 inches
  • Motor: Single speed
  • Material: Pure silicone plug, plastic bullet

5 Best Glass Butt Plugs:

The options below are a quick summary of what I consider the best glass anal toys of all time. Glass is wildly popular, in fact I published a guide and FAQ on the topic alone. For the full compilation of the best glass anal plugs, make sure to check this blog entry that features tips and techniques as well as safety precautions reserved for toys made of glass only.

Galileo Glass Plug

1. Galileo

Galileo is short and wide with a spade shaped tip is a great option because the long neck allows the tip to go extra deep compared to most other glass butt plugs. The swirled blue and yellow design in the tip is so pretty, it's like elegant adult art!

  • Total Length: 3 3/4 inches
  • Insertable Length: 3 1/2 inches
  • Diameter: Slightly over 1 1/2 inches at the thickest point, 1 inch across the shaft

Pacifier Glass Butt Plug

2. Pacifier

Pacifier is one of the best glass butt plugs because it has a smooth tip immediately followed by a bumpy shaft. The contrast feels stunning, the heavy weight adds to the erotic sensation from behind and the glass loop at the base is ideal for thrusting.

  • Total Length: 4 1/2 inches
  • Insertable Length: 3 inches
  • Width: 1 1/4 inches across the thickest part, 1 1/8 inches across the shaft

Triple Play Glass

3. Triple Play Glass

Triple Play Glass is the best glass butt plug for beginners. The gentle bulbous shaft is reminiscent and anal beads and the flat circular base tucks nicely between your cheeks. The small size has the ideal structure for the curious.

  • Total Length: 3 3/4 inches
  • Width: 3/4 inch
  • Material: Solid glass

The Juicer Glass Plug

4. The Juicer

The Juicer is a substantial glass anal toy for experts complete with long shaft and round head that digs super deep. The steady shaft has bumps around the circumference to give the muscles something to grasp while worn.

  • Total Length: 6 1/4 inches (including handle)
  • Insertable Length: 4 1/4 inches
  • Diameter: 1 1/2 inches across the tip, 1 inch across the shaft

Pink Flower Glass Plug for Women

5. Pink Flower

Pink Flower is the best glass butt plug for women with stylish feminine design. The base is a blossoming flower so it looks extra sexy and super cute when worn. Small and short size is perfect for beginners and the thin neck helps to keep it in place.

  • Total Length: 3 1/2 inches
  • Insertable Length: 3 inches
  • Width: Slightly under 1 1/4 inches across the widest part

Lube, Lube, Lube

Anal play should simply not exist without plenty of lube. The right anal lube, and enough of it, really makes the difference between enjoyable anal sex and painful anal sex. For the best anal plug experience, don’t grab the cheapest tube from the shelf at your local drugstore. Instead, take the following into consideration:

  • Get the right lube for your butt plug. Different lubes are compatible with different materials.
  • Consider a numbing lube to make your first time more comfortable.
  • Experiment with cooling or warming lubes for more pleasure.
  • Try a lube made specifically for anal sex. These tend to be thicker to stay in place longer. 

One quick but important note about numbing lubes. Be cautious when you use these. Too much lack of sensation could cause you to miss potential injuries.

Check Out These Great Lubes For Your Anal Toys

  1. Fifty Shades of Grey At Ease Anal Lubricant: This is the thickest lube in the 50 Shades of Grey collection. The cost is just over ten dollars, and the sleek sophisticated packaging is quite discreet.
  2. Body Action Anal Relaxer: This is a great option if you don’t want to use an anal desensitizer. This lube works by using natural oils that encourage users to relax their anal muscles.
  3. Uranus Anal Lube: This is a premium product, perfect for anal connoisseurs. It has a silicone base, so it lasts a long time, and it won’t rinse off under water. This is a great lube for anyone who wants a sleek, smooth experience.

Get Turned On

Sexy Butt
Looking forward to back door pleasures.

Okay, you’ve chosen the right butt plug, and have the perfect lube. It’s time for insertion. That’s not going to go well if you are tense, and not in the mood.

Relaxation is key, and so is a good mood. The more turned on you are, the better this will feel. If you’re playing with a partner, engage in some foreplay. Having an orgasm (or more!) will help you relax, and release endorphins. If you’re engaging in solo play, try masturbating to orgasm first.

Of course, having a glass of wine or two won’t hurt. Just don’t get inebriated. You need to be in tune with how you are feeling.

Take Your Sweet Time

This is not something you should rush into. Don't feel pressured to achieve full insertion on your first time. Once you have inserted your butt plug, you may only be able to keep it in for a short amount of time. That's perfectly normal. Some people take quite a long time before their able to master insertion, and feel comfortable walking around with something inside them.

Don't pressure yourself to take on more than you can handle. Don't feel as if you have to be successful on your first try. Use this butt plug guide to better understand what to expect. Also, you may find that your first butt plug just doesn't work for you. Fortunately, these toys are very reasonably priced. You can simply shop for one that is a more compatible size, shape, or material.

Wash Your Anal Plug

The truth about anal sex is that there's a lot of bacteria involved. Even if you are spotless it's just there. What you don't want to do is spread that bacteria around oh, and you don't want to introduce new bacteria to your rectum. 

One way to keep things safe and clean is to wash your hands thoroughly. Do this before and after using your butt plug, or engaging in any other anal play.

Even the best anal butt plug will become worthless if it is infested with harmful bacteria. You absolutely must wash your anal toy after you use it. Do this immediately, so that no microbes have time to grow. Follow best practices for cleaning your butt plug so that it gets clean, and lasts as long as possible. If you forget to do this, you have to simply throw it away. It simply isn’t worth the risk.

In Conclusion

Shopping for the best butt plug is a highly personal decision, but hopefully some of these product suggestions have inspired you to take a peek and find the perfect one for you. We've introduced some unique shapes, styles, materials and features that appeal to a vast range of men and women. My goal here is to make it easy to start browsing today and find the best butt plug for your erotic needs.



Click to buy butt plugs online.



Mayla Green

Mayla Green has been involved in the sex toy industry since 2004. Working behind the motto “Sex TOYS should be FUN”, Mayla provides unique tips & advice amassed from over a decade of hands on experience with adult products. She also coaches clients how to fully enjoy sexual pleasure and can be seen in major publications & magazines online.

Happily married since 2009, she knows firsthand how the sex life eventually becomes repetitive (which truthfully means boring), so if you're looking to spice things up in the bedroom, Mayla's your gal! Her literary pride & joy is covering topics for established couples needing inspiration to keep lovemaking exciting and fun.

Not in a relationship? Her other focus is teaching women how to properly handle the “little person in the canoe” to experience the best orgasms ever, no partner required! Her creative and innovative tips, techniques and advice is on par with a certified sex therapist or Sexologist, but with an extra advantage from her knowledge of the adult toy business.

View all articles published by Mayla Green exclusively for The Adult Toy Shop sex blog. Mayla Green's Linkedin profile highlights her professional background, experience and training.

Related Posts
  1. How to Use an Inflatable Butt Plug | Expanding Butt Plug Techniques How to Use an Inflatable Butt Plug | Expanding Butt Plug Techniques Watch videos of inflatable butt plugs inflate & deflate. What is an inflatable butt plug and why would a person want to try one? I can tell you exactly why, and even explain what they feel like inside the butt. They are fragile anal toys, so proper
  2. Clit Suckers & Clit Pumps | Everything You Need To Know Clit Suckers & Clit Pumps | Everything You Need To Know How do I use a clit sucker, and what does it feel like? A peculiar little sex toy for powerful female arousal. Step by step instructions on using a clit pump and a comparison of the 4 different styles that a lady can choose from. Learn details on ex
  3. Quiet Vibrators | Sound Testing 25 Silent Vibrators Quiet Vibrators | Sound Testing 25 Silent Vibrators What makes a vibrator quiet? And other common FAQ's. We receive plenty of questions about quiet vibrators. This guide answers everything you've ever wanted to know and even includes tips to make a noisy vibrator silent. I bring out the sound meter a
  4. Most Powerful Vibrators for Women | Reviewed & Compared Most Powerful Vibrators for Women | Reviewed & Compared Have you ever reached an orgasm in seconds with a vibrator before? Powerful vibrators are a hot commodity in the bedroom, but it's difficult to shop for one just by looking at photos online. In this buyers guide, I'll provide explanations as to why